overplay

verb4

1. •
   To overdo or overact one's effect or role.

   • When Chris overacted his part again, the director warned that anyone overplaying would be barred from the next production.
2. •
   To play (a song or record) too frequently, often to the point of causing weariness and annoyance.

   • A lot of times I don't want to overplay songs that I really like, because I know that then I'll get sick of them and I don't want to get sick of them. — 2008
3. •
   (figurative) To overestimate one's strength in a game or event, which ultimately may end in a defeat.

   • Jack won the last match of blackjack; Theo overplayed.
4. •
   To accidentally hit (one's golf ball) beyond "the green".

   • The first few shots went wonderfully, but Robin overplayed the last and lost.